Bill Bronchick

Lease/Option vs. Contract for Deed
by Bill Bronchick

Many investors are generally familiar with the concepts lease option and contract for deed (aka "installment land contract"). Many investors confuse the two, and this article will help you understand the tax, legal, and practical issues between the two.

Lease Options

First, let's start with the lease option, which is really two things, a lease and a purchase option. A lease is a contract for the use and possession of land, creating a landlord/tenant (or "lessor/lessee") relationship. A purchase option is a unilateral agreement wherein the optionor ("seller") agrees to give the optionee ("buyer") the exclusive right to the purchase the leased premises. The option price is generally set at a fixed price at the inception of the lease, although it does not have to be. At any time during the option period (which generally corresponds to the lease period), the tenant can exercise his option to purchase.

An option is not the same as a regular purchase contract, which is a bilateral agreement. A bilateral contract legally binds both parties to the agreement, whereas an option only binds the seller. An optionee is not bound to buy; it is his option do so (or not to do so). A lease with option arrangement is not a sale, but rather a landlord-tenant relationship. In rare cases, a court may re-characterize the transaction as a sale if it looks like a sale. Furthermore, the IRS does not classify a lease option as a sale until the option is exercised (see, Tax Court Memorandum 1999-11).

Contract For Deed

A contract for deed (aka "installment land contract") is an agreement wherein the buyer makes installment payments on an arrangement similar to an automobile financing. The seller holds legal title to the property as security for payment, while the buyer has "equitable" title. When the buyer pays the full amount due under the contract, the seller delivers legal title to the buyer. Equitable title gives the buyer the right to live in the property, improve it, rent it and otherwise enjoy all of the benefits of ownership. However, since the buyer does not have legal title, he cannot use it as collateral for a home equity loan (although in some states, banks will lend against an equitable interest in a contract for deed).

The IRS generally treats a contract for deed as a sale, which means the buyer has the tax benefits of ownership. Thus, the payments of interest that are made by the buyer in possession are deductible as "mortgage interest," even though the buyer does not have legal title to the property. A contract for deed seller must report the transaction as an installment sale on form IRS Form 6252. Once sold, the seller cannot claim depreciation or any other tax benefits of the property. If the buyer defaults on the contract and the seller exercises his legal option to reclaim the property, the tax code treats the transaction as a foreclosure.

The legal process for repossession of the property is not entirely clear in every state. Some state statutes (e.g., IL, TX & PA) clearly spell out the process, which is somewhat more involved than an eviction, but clearly less burdensome than a full-blown foreclosure. In most states, the process is not clearly defined, so courts deal with a buyer's default on a case-by-case basis.

Which Is Better?

In summary, the lease option is a landlord-tenant relationship until the purchase is complete; the contract for deed is a sale at the inception of the agreement. In rare cases a court may re-characterize lease option transaction as a contract for deed, but this is limited to situations where the transaction looks like sale (as in the case of a long-term lease option with a declining balance purchase price).

Which formula is better? It depends on the situation and your goals. A lease option transaction is not a sale, so you will benefit from market appreciation if the tenant declines to exercise his option to purchase. A contract for deed sale will allow you to get more a down payment from the buyer, since it "feels" more like a sale. In higher-priced neighborhoods the rents may not command enough rent to cover your underlying mortgage payments.

A contract for deed sale will allow you to collect interest payments, which are generally more than you could collect in rent. On the other hand, a property sold is already sold for tax purposes; thus, you cannot use a 1031 tax-deferred exchange on a property sold by contract for deed when the buyer pays off the debt balance. The entire balance paid on the contract will be due as a capital gain, which can be a huge tax liability if you have a low basis in the property. Furthermore, a defaulting buyer on a contract for deed is generally harder to get out of the property, particularly in a court proceeding.

Summary on the Pros and Cons of Each

The Upside Of Lease Options Are...
  • Legal control of the property
  • Ability to claim depreciation

  • Ability to defer gains by 1031x
  • The Downside Of Lease Options Are...
  • Less money down

  • Less of an incoming payment

  • Continued landlording responsibility
  • The Upside Of The CFD is...
  • More money down

  • Higher monthly income

  • No landlording headache
  • The Downside Of The CFD Is...
  • Potential tax hit

  • Transfer tax due at sale
  • You must decide on a deal by deal basis which transaction works best for you in terms of work involved, tax issues and, most importantly, cash flow. And, be flexible and know how to do both types of transactions; you can buy on a contract for deed, then re-sell on lease with option. You can buy on lease/option, sell on lease/option. You can buy on contract for deed, then rent the property out. There are multiple strategies you can use and the more you learn the more you earn!

    Bill Bronchick
    William Bronchick, CEO of Legalwiz Publications, is a Nationally-known attorney, author, entrepreneur and speaker. Mr. Bronchick has been practicing law and real estate since 1990, having been involved in over 600 transactions. He has appeared as a guest on numerous radio and television talk shows including CNBC Power Lunch. He has been featured in Who's Who in American Business, Money Magazine, the Los Angeles Times and the Denver Business Journal. William Bronchick has served as President of the Colorado Association of Real Estate Investors since 1996.

    Bill Bronchick Products (9)
    CoursesHow to Create a Bulletproof Corporation
    CoursesHow to Create Your Own LLC and Family Limited Partnership
    CoursesStep by Step Guide to Land Trusts
    CoursesUltimate Guide to Buy and Hold
    CoursesUltimate Guide to Fix and Flip
    CoursesUltimate Guide to Owner Financing
    CoursesUltimate Guide to Wholesaling
    SpecialsWealth Protection Library
    CoursesWealth Protection Strategies

    Copyright Notice
    Copyright 2002-2020 All Rights Reserved. Published with Permission of Author. No part of this publication may be copied or reprinted
    without the express written permission of the Author and/or

    Back to Top

    Free Newsletter

    Article Options
    Printer Friendly Page
    Send This to Friend

    Author's Articles
    10 Easy Tips for Finding Investment Properties
    10 Inexpensive Ways to Spruce Up Your Rental or Rehab Property
    60 Days To Your First Bargain Purchase
    7 Real Estate Contract Buyer Clauses Checklist
    7 Reasons to Use a Land Trust
    7 Ways To Buy Foreclosure Property
    9 Goal Setting Tips For Real Estate Investors
    9 Mistakes New Real Estate Investors Make
    A Review of the National Consumer Law Center
    All About Property Disclosures
    Apartment Investing - Investors Now Is the Perfect Time!
    Are Real Estate Seminars Worth the Money?
    Are You a Newbie at a Real Estate Club?
    Are You Clear On What is a Good Deal
    Are You Waiting on the Sidelines?
    Bankruptcy, Foreclosure, & Credit - How it Affects You
    Bankruptcy, Foreclosure, & Credit - Part II
    Basics of the Real Estate Contract
    Be a Smart Investor... Do the Math
    Big Brother Is Watching You, New (Bad) Legislation Coming Your Way
    Bubble, Schmubble - Flipping Works in Any Market
    Bull vs. Bubble
    Bulletproof Your Wealth with Family Limited Partnerships and LLC's
    Buy A House - Get Thrown in Jail?
    Buying at the Foreclosure Auction
    Collecting Money Owed by a Tenant
    Common Investor Legal Mistakes
    Common Sense Mortgage Tips
    Contents of a Good Short Sale Package
    Contract for Deed
    Create Monthly Cash Flow Without Any of Your Own Money or Credit
    Dealing with Real Estate Agents
    Dealing with the Dealer Issue
    Dealing With the Due on Sale Clause - Part II
    Do You Need a License to Flip Real Estate?
    Equity Sharing & Partnerships
    Essential Contract Clauses
    Essential Contract Clauses II
    Explaining Foreclosure Options to the Homeowner
    Five Big Mistakes Newbies Make
    Flipping Properties for Cash Profit
    Flipping Versus Holding - Which is Better?
    Get That Property Out of Your Name!
    Getting Started as a Real Estate Entrepreneur
    How Much Cash Should an Investor Keep in Reserve?
    How to Create a Real Estate Cash Cow
    How to Determine Property Values in Today's Market
    How to Get a Hard Money Loan
    How to Save Up to 90% on Title Insurance
    HUD Properties, FHA & Title Seasoning
    Illegal Flipping and Lender Seasoning
    Investing in a Changing Market
    Investing Outside of Your Local Area
    Investing Strategy - Master Lease Option for Apartments
    Keep a Positive Perspective in a Negative Market
    Know Your Real Estate Laws
    Learn the Landlord-Tenant Rules!
    Lease Option a Junker!
    Lease Option Tips & Strategies
    Lease/Option 101
    Lease/Option vs. Contract for Deed
    Lease/Options & the Equitable Interest
    Mortgage Broker vs. Mortgage Banker
    Non-Income Verification Loans
    Owner Financing Mechanics
    Personal Property Trusts
    Real Estate Investing Financing 101
    Real Estate Investing is Just Like Weight Loss
    Reduce Taxes By Investing In Real Estate
    Risks of Buying Real Estate in Emerging Markets Out of State
    Scripting Common Objections from Foreclosure Sellers
    Setting Your Financial Goals
    Seven Ways to Flip a Property
    Should the Government Bail Out People in Foreclosure?
    Should You Disclose on Short Sale Flips?
    Should You Do Real Estate Full-Time?
    Should You Use an Attorney's Fee Clause?
    Tax Issues on a Subject 2 Deal
    Tax Lien Investing 101
    Ten Myths Preventing People from Succeeding in Real Estate Investing
    The Basics of "Short Sales"
    The Bona Fide Purchaser
    The Ethical Real Estate Investor
    The Forgotten Owner Carry
    The Mortgage Elimination
    The New Limited Liability Company
    The Not-So-Handy Man's Guide to Fixing and Flipping Properties
    The Property Recording System
    The Role of Insurance in Asset Protection Planning
    The Wrong Way to Invest in Real Estate
    There is No Due on Sale Jail
    Top Ten Ways to Get Sued - Guaranteed!
    Understanding Loan Terms
    Understanding The Mortgage Loan Market
    Using A Home Equity Line Of Credit To Buy Properties
    Using a LLC IRA for Real Estate Investing
    Using Facebook as a Real Estate Investor
    Using Trusts for Personal & Business Privacy
    What Every Landlord Should Know About Discrimination
    What to Do if a Tenant Abandons the Property
    What You Need to Ask Before Joining a Coaching Program
    Where to Incorporate: The Answer May Surprise You!
    You Have to Sell a House to Get it Sold
    Zero In On Motivated Sellers

    Author's Products

    How to Create a Bulletproof Corporation

    How to Create Your Own LLC and Family Limited Partnership

    Step by Step Guide to Land Trusts

    Ultimate Guide to Buy and Hold

    Ultimate Guide to Fix and Flip

    Ultimate Guide to Owner Financing

    Ultimate Guide to Wholesaling

    Wealth Protection Library

    Wealth Protection Strategies